You have numbered your properties with [sticky] tags, but they display on your site in reverse order.
Why this happens. Third-party "custom post order" plugins, such as Simple Custom Post Order, and custom code snippets that force a sort order on properties conflict with the built-in ordering. This can display your property list backwards.
What to do. If your order appears exactly reversed:
- Remove the property post type from the settings of any such plugin.
- Deactivate any snippet that forces properties to sort by menu order.
The built-in [sticky] ordering then comes through as intended.